01-11-2016, 08:15 PM
(01-11-2016, 07:29 PM)Murphyv310 Wrote: Hi Mark.
What we want here is a decent drive for the EL84. On the face of it 25V P-P will be fine but with the values used to get that amount of drive there will be loads of distortion. With the "correct" values you could be getting 100V P-P or more with the same distortion but your EL84 will be driven hard so reducing the input or volume will reduce the distortion and you'll still have enough drive to get 3-3.5 watts of undistorted output.
I assume you're talking about distortion from the first stage? I'd like to learn more about this. I'm studying the datasheet for that valve, but I'm not seeing a transconductance curve. I expect to see something that shows the exponential relationship between Vg and Ia, and from that curve, I'd be able to choose a decent quiescent current for the valve to work at. From the curves I can see, I don't really see a problem with 7.5mA, beyond a lack of voltage gain because of standard "gm times Rl" stuff - the same basic principles you apply to solid state amplifiers.
There are some tables in the datasheet that report distortion for various values of anode current and anode resistor, and they don't vary much (4-6%, which seems pretty high to me). The lowest resistor I see is 47k, and that's with a 1k2 cathode resistor.
Either way, I did suggest that each stage can be tested in isolation - this is a really valuable technique and I don't understand why it's not already been done as part of the troubleshooting, given the luxury of no overall NFB. Just a photo of a 'scope trace developing 25V pk-pk would be interesting. The results from a distortion analyser is even better if Andy has one. But, break it down, and work out the problems of each stage in isolation. Isn't that what everyone does?
(01-11-2016, 07:29 PM)Murphyv310 Wrote: Personally I don't like low value volume controls for the reason that it can cause bass roll off due to the time constants of the input "R" of the VC vs coupling cap or the coupling in the source.
One drawback of a high value volume control is thermal noise. It depends on how much gain follows, and how noise-free that gain is, but with good solid-state design, the noise of just a 50k pot could easily be the dominant source of noise in the entire system. Perhaps not in this context, sure, but that's the philosophy behind avoiding high values, and it's basic, well-established stuff. Some state of the art devices use 1k potentiometers! The high impedances seen in valve gear is more about cost saving that anything else.
As I've said, LF roll-off in this context is academic with modern gear. Different if you're building an amp to work with valve sources (that are often too mean to include a cathode follower and a decently sized output cap), but again, Andy is building this for modern gear.







