01-11-2016, 06:27 PM
Yes, now you mention it, it does seem rather low. But when I saw "25V p-p AC" on the diagram, I assumed that the triode stage was working OK. But was that value the intention rather than the actual value observed?
The value of the volume control is irrelevant - it merely sets in the input impedance (and influences the value of the input capacitor). Andy specifically mentioned the source equipment he plans to use with this, and it's modern gear that works into low impedances like 10k or 50k with no issues. In audio design, always go low if you can
While I can see that the value of the cathode resistance on the triode depends on the "Vgs" of the valve and the desired "collector current", I lack the experience to say if he's chosen well there or not. With 5V there, that's 7.5mA. Across the 12k resistor, that results in a drop of 90V, which sounds pretty plausible on the face of it, but what would be the optimum "collector current" for that valve? If nothing else, that 12k will dissipate more heat that it needs to if a lower current gives equal or better results. Certainly, the circuits I've seen do indeed use the values you suggest...
Forgive the use of solid-state terms in quotes, but I find the analogies help me.
Taken in the round, insufficient voltage gain from the triode would result in insufficient voltage gain overall. But that won't give distortion, surely? As there's no overall feedback yet, it would be easy to check the triode in isolation. And indeed, it would be easy to check the second stage, totally in isolation, providing Andy has an oscillator with a highish output voltage. I'm still suspicious of that transformer. But now I look again, some supply decoupling between the two stages wouldn't be a bad idea
The value of the volume control is irrelevant - it merely sets in the input impedance (and influences the value of the input capacitor). Andy specifically mentioned the source equipment he plans to use with this, and it's modern gear that works into low impedances like 10k or 50k with no issues. In audio design, always go low if you can

While I can see that the value of the cathode resistance on the triode depends on the "Vgs" of the valve and the desired "collector current", I lack the experience to say if he's chosen well there or not. With 5V there, that's 7.5mA. Across the 12k resistor, that results in a drop of 90V, which sounds pretty plausible on the face of it, but what would be the optimum "collector current" for that valve? If nothing else, that 12k will dissipate more heat that it needs to if a lower current gives equal or better results. Certainly, the circuits I've seen do indeed use the values you suggest...
Forgive the use of solid-state terms in quotes, but I find the analogies help me.
Taken in the round, insufficient voltage gain from the triode would result in insufficient voltage gain overall. But that won't give distortion, surely? As there's no overall feedback yet, it would be easy to check the triode in isolation. And indeed, it would be easy to check the second stage, totally in isolation, providing Andy has an oscillator with a highish output voltage. I'm still suspicious of that transformer. But now I look again, some supply decoupling between the two stages wouldn't be a bad idea







