16-11-2015, 02:07 PM
I've seen debates about balance resistors or no balance resistors - all good fun 
On balance (sorry!), I fall on the side of not fitting them. Why? Because - and this is something that no-one ever mentions during the debates - high value film resistors eventually drift high, and can fail open-circuit. How long this takes is hard to predict, but Murphy's Law says that two identical resistors will not fail together!
This "voltage-stress" mechanism is the primary cause of start-up faults in switched-mode power supplies, of course. My "rule of thumb" is the "rule of 100s" - i.e. anything greater than 100k and anything greater than 100V. Although I've seen it happen to 47k resistors with around 50V across them. Note, of course, that this is nothing to do with their power dissipation being exceeded, and also nothing to do with their headline voltage limit. I've said plenty about this elsewhere, so won't repeat myself...
But, assume one of the two fails O/C, and ask what'll happen to the voltage across the other capacitor...
In practice, a capacitor acts a little bit like a Zener diode. So if one of them is leaking a little bit more than the other, then the other cap will reach a point where it begins to leak more, and when it is leaking by the same as the first, everything balances out. It's self-limiting. It doesn't matter than the voltages across each cap are unequal. They will be anyway because of the difference in capacitance...
Another factor is the heat dissipation of resistors that are actually passing enough current to swamp the expected leakage currents. In a small enclosed space, this heat is unwelcome and will hasten the demise of the new capacitors.

On balance (sorry!), I fall on the side of not fitting them. Why? Because - and this is something that no-one ever mentions during the debates - high value film resistors eventually drift high, and can fail open-circuit. How long this takes is hard to predict, but Murphy's Law says that two identical resistors will not fail together!
This "voltage-stress" mechanism is the primary cause of start-up faults in switched-mode power supplies, of course. My "rule of thumb" is the "rule of 100s" - i.e. anything greater than 100k and anything greater than 100V. Although I've seen it happen to 47k resistors with around 50V across them. Note, of course, that this is nothing to do with their power dissipation being exceeded, and also nothing to do with their headline voltage limit. I've said plenty about this elsewhere, so won't repeat myself...
But, assume one of the two fails O/C, and ask what'll happen to the voltage across the other capacitor...
In practice, a capacitor acts a little bit like a Zener diode. So if one of them is leaking a little bit more than the other, then the other cap will reach a point where it begins to leak more, and when it is leaking by the same as the first, everything balances out. It's self-limiting. It doesn't matter than the voltages across each cap are unequal. They will be anyway because of the difference in capacitance...
Another factor is the heat dissipation of resistors that are actually passing enough current to swamp the expected leakage currents. In a small enclosed space, this heat is unwelcome and will hasten the demise of the new capacitors.








