21-10-2023, 03:57 PM
(This post was last modified: 21-10-2023, 03:59 PM by Mike Watterson.)
(20-10-2023, 02:54 PM)Jez Wrote: I'd not be using batteries! Hence the CCS power for filaments. I can't see how the published specs allow anywhere near those outputs.
Constant voltage is simpler and fine. CCS might be the fashion for valves, but I've seen no evidence that it superior to a good design otherwise. The filaments have a significant temperature co-efficient, especially the 1j24b.
Class A has 50% efficiency.
True Class B push pull is much better and you double the power because two devices. It's almost 79% efficiency for linear RF. Audio might want a little more bias (some variation of class AB). Class C is only good for CW, digital OOK, FM and RTTY or similar.
Also regular audio has a lower average power (so called RMS power) than a continuous sinewave. The power is actually limited by the filament on direct cathode battery valve, hence take care to run at 1.1V to 1.2V on power amps and decouple the centre tap on series 1j29b. Due to poorer filament tolerances than the Western 1.4V 50mA nickel or 1.4V 25mA tungsten any series operation of multiple valves needs select on test and ballast resistors as different models are all different currents like the low profile 1940s German metal can valves (used till 1950). When designing for parallel only the filaments can be optimised to reduce power. The 1.4V 50mA Octal Sylvania, 1.4V 50mA B7G RCA and 1.4V 25mA B7G Philips designs deliberately use the same filaments (not optimised) to allow series or parallel operation. The series only mains valves (U, C, H, P) are optimised which is why the higher power ones progressively use higher volts.
The rated figures are for particular life and performance. Philips on the LX527AB and similar Push-Pull DL94 pair (A Philips made part) uses 153V HT (after subtracting LT) on mains. The Philips datasheet has 120V!
The limit on battery valves, especially the rod pentodes, is ultimately average filament temperature.
So 1W Pa gives 1W max audio and uses 2W in Class A.
But 1W PA is 2W Pa on Class B, because there are two. That then is about 7W audio (At 78% that's 0.78 x total 9W). So a 400mW Pa for two valves in Class B would be nearly 3W. If filament is at low end of recommended volts, then 4W at reasonable life.
If it was parallel Class A like an FT101 using 6146, 40W Pa is total 80 W Pa (because there are two) and 80W RF. But if a wideband transformer was used (that was big enough!) then a pair of 6146 would give 280W instead using Class B. They didn't do that because such an RF transformer would be very expensive and the mains transformer HT would be increased from 160W approx to 360W! Cheap to get 80W by two 40W tubes in parallel. Though people think it's a 100W rig.
FM or CW only rigs are simpler. Class C. Can beat Class D on a good day.
Digital at sau 16 QAM or higher needs a progressively more linear design. A Class B RF TX can to an extent cheat with filtering.







